Follow us

42 Suffolk Street, Sag Harbor, NY

Beautiful Greek Revival built in the 1860s offers all the charm of a 19th century home with the comfort and convenience of today due to the sophisticated redesign by top designers. The property is located on a coveted street in the heart of Sag Harbor Village and includes two beautiful, rare outbuildings. Upon entering the main house, one is welcomed into a foyer which leads to a large gallery or into an elegant living room with fireplace. A side entrance accesses a mudroom leading into the cook’s kitchen outfitted with professional appliances, a butler’s serving pantry and oversized center island. Adjacent to the kitchen is a light-filled formal dining room overlooking the lushly landscaped backyard. The main house features 4 bedrooms and 2.5 baths including the first-floor master ensuite with vaulted ceiling and abundant natural light. As was customary in houses built in the 1800’s, a back staircase takes you from the guest rooms to the kitchen. The finished lower level displays a gorgeous stone-walled family room with fireplace and includes radiant heat flooring, a stunning hearth and laundry area. The pool house offers a wood burning fireplace and full bath. A garage which is currently being used as an artist’s studio with a wood burning fireplace is a perfect sanctuary for writing or those seeking solace during busy times of the year. Mature landscaping, complete with rose gardens, compliments an outdoor oasis featuring a heated gunite pool, outdoor shower, alfresco kitchen/grilling and lounge areas. Moments from Sag Harbor restaurants, shops, Bay Street Theater and marina.

Kimberly Kakerbeck
[email protected]
c: 917-374-5985

Listing Link


Price: $3,975,000
Sq. Ft.2,700
Lot Size0.34 acres